About Me

My photo
Troy Nahumko is an award-winning author based in Caceres, Spain. His recent work focuses on travels around the Mediterranean, from Tangier to Istanbul. As a writer and photographer he has contributed to newspapers and media such as Lonely Planet, The Boston Review, The Globe and Mail, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Toronto Star, Counterpunch,The Irish World, The Straits Times, The Calgary Herald, Khaleej Times, DW-World, Rabble and El Pais. He also writes a bi-weekly op-ed column 'Camino a Ítaca' for the Spanish newspaper HOY. His book, Stories Left in Stone, Trails and Traces in Cáceres, Spain is published by the University of Alberta Press.As an ESL materials writer he has worked with publishers such as Macmillan and CUP.
Showing posts with label Monarchy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Monarchy. Show all posts

Saturday, September 17, 2022

Hereditary Privilege


If you happen to have turned on the news this past week you might have been surprised to see that only one event seems to have happened across the entire globe. The Queen has left the building. In this week's Camino a Ítaca I look at the succession from the perspective of a Canadian who has emmigrated to another country.  You can click over and see the original version in Spanish in el HOY or read the English below. (PDF en castellano abajo)

Last week my fellow Canadians woke up to drastic change. While they dreamed of grizzly bears, ice hockey, extended personal space and maple syrup, something half a world away took place that changed the way their lives were run. Without consultation, discussion or even politely being asked, they woke up to a new head of state. Like waking up to the worst hangover Las Vegas, Ibiza or Magaluf can offer, the people north of the 49th parallel woke up to King Charles III.

After 70 years on the throne of the United Kingdom, his mother, Queen Elizabeth II had sadly passed away and after a lifetime of waiting in the wings, Charles the Anxious finally had to go to work.

What does the passing of a foreign monarch have to do with a G7 member state you might ask? Why would the death of a Queen across the Atlantic Ocean have anything to do with Canada?

Well, it’s because Elizabeth was their head of state until she passed and when she did, her heir automatically became the King of Canada. True, it’s not only Canada, but also Australia, New Zealand, Jamaica, Belize and more South Pacific islands than you knew existed.

Many have the idea that this freakish incident of history has something to do with the vaunted Commonwealth, but in fact it doesn’t. Independent countries like India, Pakistan, Nigeria and Malta are also member states of the Commonwealth, but these nations sagaciously choose to elect their heads of state from amongst their own citizens. Yes, citizens, not subjects.

Elizabeth was loved in Canada and remembered for her fortitude during the Second World War. A war in which many Canadians died. My own 76-year-old mother can’t even recall life without her being Queen. Once, when the Queen was going to visit my province of Alberta, an extravagant bathroom was built in the middle of the wilderness for her in the Canadian Rockies in the event she should be indisposed.

Charles is another case.

He has never been forgiven for his treatment of Diana, someone who Canadians, overwhelmingly, did like. His callous behaviour after her death only solidified the image of someone completely out of touch. An image he only went on to worsen by flying around the world in private jets lecturing on the need to be sustainable or telling people they didn’t look ‘British’ because they were brown. The memes of him struggling with pens have only made things worse. Now, he’s the ‘defender of the faith’. Notice the exclusiveness of the definite article.

But all this absurdity really has nothing to do with people or personalities. A King can be better or worse. They can be closet racists, lascivious buffoons, journalist assassins, or well-prepared Canadian-educated technocrats but in the end they are still sovereigns. Unelected heads of state that normally can only be removed by serious civil unrest or worse yet, all-out rebellion.

Countries like Australia, Jamaica, Belize and Antigua and Barbuda had started consultations on constitutional reform and had been planning to truly become independent well before the Queen’s passing and now this will only speed up.

Hangovers can be worthwhile if you had your fun. But if it means seeing Charles’ mug  every time you look at your currency, time to move on.


Friday, June 10, 2022

Anachronisms

"Aren't the 'colonies' curious my dear?"

In this week's Camino a Ítaca, a less jubliant Royal Jubilee. Click over to read the original piece in Spanish in el HOY or read the English version below.

What do such diverse countries as Antigua and Barbuda, Australia, the Bahamas, Belize, Canada, Great Britain, Grenada, Jamaica, New Zealand, Papua New Guinea, Solomon Islands, St. Kitts and Nevis, St. Lucia, St. Vincent and the Grenadines and Tuvalu all have in common? 

If you’re having trouble finding a common thread between such vastly different nations, I wouldn’t be surprised. After all, they span the globe and range from huge frozen spaces, such as my native Canada, to tiny South Pacific nations that are difficult to find on the map.

Still struggling? Here’s a hint, Barbados used to be part of the group.

That was until last year when the Caribbean Island nation made the bold move to right a wrong that began in the 1600’s and took their final step in becoming a fully sovereign nation. The country came of age and replaced the Queen of England as head of state with an elected representative and became a republic. And it is just the latest Caribbean country to do so. In 1970, Guyana dropped the Queen as its head of state, followed by Trinidad and Tobago in 1976, and Dominica in 1978. Mauritius, way out in the Indian Ocean, left the club in 1992.

While it may come as a surprise, the rest of the countries on that list all have Queen Elizabeth as head of state. In these countries, known as Commonwealth realms, the queen appoints a representative, such as a governor general which is generally recommended by the popularly elected leader, such as the prime minister or president but the queen remains head of state.

Sometimes these countries are confused with other members of the Commonwealth. Most of whose members are simply states, like India, Kenya and Malaysia, with close ties to the United Kingdom. These do not have the queen as their monarch and who elect a head of state from among their own people.

But these are tough times for those with blue blood. Life is no longer just a steady stream of Vega Sicilia and jilted former lovers. During a recent tour of the Caribbean, Prince William and Kate, the Duchess of Cambridge were greeted by more protests than admiration as they drove around in colonialist parades. Local protesters in Belize and Jamaica called for a formal apology by the royals for their family’s role in the enslavement and brutalization of Africans and demanded reparations. Something they refuse to do.

As they treated their sunburns back home, Belize, the Bahamas, Jamaica, Grenada, Antigua and Barbuda, and St. Kitts and Nevis all announced plans to follow Barbados’ lead.

Then another royal shock happened over the weekend, not in Sanxenxo, but in our antipodes. Australia ousted their populist right wing Prime Minister and elected Anthony Albanese. The Labor leader is an avowed republican who has stated that Australia should hold a referendum to remove the queen as head of State.

Growth and change are inevitable. As these brave nations have shown, coming of age and becoming a truly democratic country does not have to be traumatic. The word ‘republic’ doesn’t have to mean rebellion. It simply means choice. The power to choose heads of state and peacefully oust them if and when necessary.

Saturday, February 20, 2021

Jailing Songbirds

The bins are burning in Barcelona again (remind me to get into the replacement business there) for, what on the surface has been sold as a freedom of speech issue. And while freedom of speech does play a significant role in the case of a rapper sent to prison, his right to an opinion is eclipsed and sullied with the violence he espouses. This week's Camino a Ítaca looks at the need for free speech and those that I love listening to who have long demanded it. You can read the originally published piece here in Spanish or the English below. (version en castellano en PDF tambien abajo)

Rap just never did it for me. The ethereal sound of Johnny Hodges soloing over a Duke Ellington melody, the frantic fretboard work of Buddy Guy, the earnest exhortation to 'respect yourself' from Mavis Staples or the slick groove of Nile Rodger's Le Freak are all examples of Black music that I couldn't even conceive of life without. Rap though, just never resonated with me. I can appreciate it from a sociological perspective and recognize the undeniably crucial role that it has played in the black community throughout its ongoing struggle, but it just doesn't hit me the same way as Billie Holiday rasping about strange fruit swinging from the trees in the southern breeze.

But one thing is not to like it and another is to be sent to court for it.

Cities are burning at night in Spain for the words of an artist. An artist who has been sent to prison for praising terrorists and inciting violence, messages that clearly have no place in a modern democracy. What I can't understand though is that he has also been found guilty and fined for insulting a medieval idea, for insulting the 'crown'. It's something straight out of a Monty Python sketch or Mel Brooks movie, and would be as comical, if it wasn't so serious. Apparently it still is good to be the king and heaven forbid that one of his subjects were to question his divine right. If a hereditary job title wasn't atavistic enough, fining someone for the equivalent of scribbling on the bathroom walls is antediluvian. It's as absurd as taking a necromancer to court because they gave you the wrong lottery numbers or your pyromancer because she gave you the wrong job advice. It's a blind leap into a very dark past.

Paraphrasing Salman Rushdie, a man who knows a thing or two about medieval beliefs impinging on his freedoms, he once wrote that creativity not only needs freedom in order to thrive, but the very assumption of freedom. If an artist worries about whether or not they will be thrown in jail for their work in the future, then they are not free today. If there is a climate of fear regarding what you can do, create or say, then their art will not be shaped and determined by their talents but by fear.

Censorship is on the rise, and it's not only coming from fanciful crowns, conservative judiciaries or turbaned islamofascists. Interest groups, faith groups, gender warriors, anti-bull fighting lobbies, and safe-zone universities are all guilty of attempting to sanitize discussion and thought by censoring it completely. And for what? For fear of offending somebody, for fear of saying that Thor's hammer only exists in Marvel movies, for fear of hurting someone's feelings? This self-censorship not only stifles creativity but also drives loonier ideas into fetid, dark corners, allowing them to mutate and multiply rather than be exposed to the blinding light of truth and reason. If what the rapper said was indeed untrue, confront it with facts, not with excessive fines and prison sentences.

Blasphemy, elves, insults to the crown and those that wear them belong in fairy tales and have no place in modern legal codes. I may not like rap, but it's looking like we need to listen to the great man from Jamaica and Get Up and Stand Up, otherwise Sam Cooke's promised change will never come.

Saturday, August 8, 2020

WANTED

 

This week's stroll along the Camino a Ítaca circles back to Azerbaijan and beyond. Memories of images of Strong Men, Royalty and Dictators crying out to be loved and admired. Read the English version below or click over to the published version in Spanish. 


Even though it was against my better judgement, I just had to take the picture. Travel around the world and you soon learn the differences between places regarding where you can and can’t take pictures. Selfies at sunset for your Instagram account are just fine but if they happen to be next to a military complex or top secret laboratory, you’re better off to either take it very discreetly or simply wait until that next orange sky. That is, of course, if you don’t want to face some uncomfortable questioning that isn’t exactly focused on how happy you are with the buffet at the hotel.

But this one I just had to have.

We had been living in Azerbaijan for months by then and had become almost inured to the ever-present moustachioed faces of the great leader or his deceased father looking down on you. In some photos they were dressed up in military fatigues bursting at the gut. Others saw them trying, and failing, to look debonair, donning their tailored Savile Row suits. But the most tragicomic were those that had them dressed up in traditional garments, frolicking with their subjects. Subjects that would have been boiled in hot oil if they refused to take part in the montage. This one though, was different.

We were near the Nagorno-Karabakh region, close to the frontline where Azeri and Armenian soldiers still stare down the sights of their guns at each other, when I saw it. There they were, father and son together in dark sunglasses and 1960’s style turtlenecks, looking like villains that had just stepped out of a vintage James Bond movie.

I got out of the car and raised my camera and took the shot only to see out of the corner of my eye some military guards in their unmistakable soviet-style top hats start to shout and run towards me. Even though they were probably only looking for a small bribe to help feed their families, I didn’t fancy going through the elaborate ceremony situations like these involve and we took off down the road.

I have always held a morbid curiosity for the omnipresent pictures of Dear Leaders and their close counterparts, monarchs that you can see around the world. What purpose do action shots of the aforementioned Bond villains, tattered pictures of the King of Morocco in the most remote shop in the High Atlas, the God King of Thailand staring out of a rusted frame or the head  of the Queen of England stamped on every coin in Canada really serve? Are they desperate attempts to constantly validate their dominion over others. Like surreal WANTED posters or Tinder profile pictures that in fact should read, WANT ME: looking for love and admiration? Or are they simply narcissistic gestures to appease the hyper-inflated egos of people whose position leads them to believe they are superior to lesser mortals?

Dress them up however you want though but it won’t change the fact that their roles are immoral and unjust. Disguise a king up as a great warrior, a cosmopolitan diplomat or even a circus monkey and it won’t change the fact that a hereditary monarchy is as anachronistic as a Strong Man in the Caucasus or a bad haircut in North Korea. It’s time these idols are taken off the walls and put into the dusty drawers of history where they belong. 

Sunday, July 26, 2020

Of Apples and Saudi Offerings


In Aden, Yemeni activists still live in fear

Next stop on the Camino a Ítaca, a look back more than fifteen years to a taxi ride across Crater in Aden, Yemen and a curious perspective on colonialism. Click over here for the published Spanish version or read the English version below. 


From the outside it looked like most of the taxis that you see across the developing world. Years of ferrying people across crumbling roads, and often lack thereof, take their toll on these essential services. Here in Aden, Yemen, where few people own their own car, they are even more vital, as this biblical city is set on peninsula broken up into three distinct and very separate parts.

It’s a city that is at least as old as written history. Some say when the book of Ezekiel speaks of the Garden of Eden, it was referring to this baking volcanic rock that sticks out into the gulf of Aden. If indeed it once was a lush, green playground for the forbearers of humankind, the punishment was severe. Times have since changed and all that is left is rock, sand and dust.

As we got in, I quickly noticed that this wasn’t your average taxi. A suspicion that was proven true when the wizened old driver turned around and asked me, in an English that would have sounded familiar to his ex-colonial rulers, where we wanted to go.

I found out that he had worked for the English before they were expelled in the late 1960’s and hadn’t forgotten a word since. As he fondly reminisced about life under British colonial rule, I couldn’t help but ask if he didn’t prefer living in the current, albeit flawed democracy. “Democracy!” he spat, “give me a king like they have in Oman, Saudi Arabia or even our old ruler the Queen of England any day.” The anti-monarchist in me grew curious, even if it meant that his driving got even more erratic as he became more excited. “Kings rob at the beginning of their rule but as they get comfortable, they let some crumbs fall for the common people. These ‘democrats’ though, only have four years and steal everything, leaving nothing behind for us!”

Greed however is one of the most addictive of the cardinal sins and once you get a taste for expensive Vega Sicilia wine, it’s hard to drink the local pitarras. When Juan Carlos betrayed his fascist minders and opted for democracy over dictatorship, even war criminals the likes of Henry Kissinger congratulated him. It looked like a new Garden of Eden and a literal example of having your cake and eating it too.

His decision though, is less magnanimous than it seems. The West was increasingly uncomfortable with the anachronism of a dictatorship in its midst, so why not change a caudillo for a king? Europe is full of moth-eaten parliamentary monarchies that retain the medieval idea of hereditary heads of state. So why not one more?

Unlike his generous Saudi friends though, constitutional monarchs are terrorised by ballot boxes. The chance that their subjects might outgrow their sadomasochistic urge to be dominated disturbs their pampered sleep. Here’s where the taxi driving Methuselah might have been half right, this anxiety seems to drive ‘democratic’ monarchs to develop a taste for the crumbs too.

But even if they do, everyone has the right to the presumption of innocence, ex-kings included. A trial by the media is as immoral and as unfair as a monarchy. This citizen deserves the same as other mortals, a trial in a court of law. Only then will even the most submissive masochist see that magnates need to be shown the exit of Eden.  

Wednesday, March 29, 2017

A Bit of a Warning?

Writing in the local paper. Local issues with a global take. I never translate literally and the editor trims at will to make it fit. Here's my version, then theirs.

The Queen paid a visit to Caceres the other day. Sorry, I should probably be more precise, I don’t mean the ex-journalist who is the darling of all the fashion magazines, but the one who, like me, can’t get rid of that stubborn accent from elsewhere. In these days of having two kings, two truths, two popes etc, things can indeed get a bit confusing. But as the refrain about the legendary Spanish generosity goes, donde comen tres, comen cuatro (where three can eat, so can four). Even in these difficult times when hospital beds are being cut back and people are expected to retire after they die, why not have two queens? And if the trains out to this part of her realm aren’t to her liking, well let's send a helicopter to pick her up. Anyways, don’t feel bad if you didn’t know about her visit, I only found that she was here when I saw the police towing my neighbors’ cars away for security measures, and I live in the old town. I had suspected something was up as I walked home and noticed more police that pedestrians but my suspicions were confirmed when I overheard an officer talking to a neighbor. The poor guy had just found out that his car had been towed away and the policeman was telling him that he shouldn’t be upset because he hadn’t been fined, though I’m not sure his taxi fare to pick it up will be included with the helicopter in the budget. It seems that la doña Sofia was here to attend a concert that in part was sponsored by the town hall and el Grupo Ciudades Patrimonio de la Humanidad de España. I found myself wishing that Iberdrola, the electricty company or even the water comany had also been part of this and the in the process they could have shown the town hall the way that they actually inform residents about something that is going to affect them a day or two in advance. The fact that TVE (Spanish National TV) was here with the queen will surely help promote our fair city but I’m sure that this wasn’t a state secret and a few signs the night before would have appeased even the most virulent republican.  

Moving Shop

  We've moved house. This blog has moved to  https://troynahumko.com/ See you over there!