About Me

My photo
Troy Nahumko is an award-winning author based in Caceres, Spain. His recent work focuses on travels around the Mediterranean, from Tangier to Istanbul. As a writer and photographer he has contributed to newspapers and media such as Lonely Planet, The Boston Review, The Globe and Mail, The Sydney Morning Herald, The Toronto Star, Counterpunch,The Irish World, The Straits Times, The Calgary Herald, Khaleej Times, DW-World, Rabble and El Pais. He also writes a bi-weekly op-ed column 'Camino a Ítaca' for the Spanish newspaper HOY. His book, Stories Left in Stone, Trails and Traces in Cáceres, Spain is published by the University of Alberta Press.As an ESL materials writer he has worked with publishers such as Macmillan and CUP.
Showing posts with label catholisism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label catholisism. Show all posts

Saturday, August 6, 2022

No 'Mea' and No 'Culpa'

In this week's Camino a Ítaca I take a trip back to the tundra and where I'm from to look at Pope Francis' Not-Really-Sorry tour of Canada. Click over to read the original in Spanish in el HOY or have a look at the English translation below. (PDF en castellano abajo)

I’m from the last big city you pass as you head up into the great expanses of the Canadian north. It’s one of the northernmost cities in the world with a population of over a million people, lying at around the same latitude as Moscow. It’s a city that few have heard of and even fewer have visited and usually only makes the news during the winter to say that it is one of the coldest places on earth. That is until last week.

I watched in surprise as journalists from CNN, Aljazeera and the BBC reported from the river valley where I grew up. National newspapershere in Spain featured places I knew well and for a brief moment the place I used to call home was a prominent feature on the 24-hour news cycle.

My hometown was introduced to the world as Jorge Maria Bergoglio, better known as Pope Francis, came for a visit.

This, however, wasn’t one of the standard pastoral visits designed to simply give believers a chance to see the head of the church. This was a trip with a different purpose. One that was only undertaken after years of repeatedly being asked to do so. He came with the stated intention to apologize directly and personally to indigenous peoples for the Catholic Church's role in the government funded residential school system. A Canadian system that was imposed on Indigenous peoples as part of a broad set of assimilation efforts to destroy their rich cultures and identities and to suppress their histories. It was a system that existed until the late 1990s and one that the Canadian government has described as cultural genocide in their truth and reconciliation commission.

The brutal sexual, emotional and psychological abuse inflicted on the institutions’ inmates has been investigated and documented for years. But it was the recent discovery of hundreds of unmarked children’s graves found on the grounds of schools across the country that drove indigenous leaders to travel to the Vatican to ask the Pope directly for some sort of recognition and accountability.

After decades of requests, the church finally relented. Anticipation was high as the Argentinian landed on the great plains and many believers and non-believers alike eagerly attended the open-air meeting to hear the apology they had so long waited for.

But no institutional mea culpa was to be found. Instead they got a tepid apology ‘for the wrong done by so many Christians to the Indigenous peoples.’ There was no mention of the thousands of cases of sexual abuse and no hint at the perhaps thousands of graves still waiting to be uncovered. According to the church, it shared no institutional responsibility and these grotesque acts were the misdoings of private individuals.

Even though Indigenous people from coast-to-coast had been calling for papal bulls that make up the Doctrine of Discovery, which is in effect a doctrine of colonization, to be rescinded, the Pope completely avoided any mention of culpability.

Seen from afar, this complete dereliction of responsibility could be expected. After all, this is an institution that believes its leader is infallible. What mystifies me is the continued desire to believe in it. 

Sunday, October 18, 2020

One of Us

My bit on the ongoing creep of 'one of us' thought here in Spain and around the world in the next stage of the Camino a Ítaca. Read the English below or click over to the original published in el Hoy. Tambien se puede ver el original en castellano abajo en PDF.

I have to admit that I didn’t even know that something like Eurovision even existed until I had actually lived in Spain for a few years. When I did finally discover it though, it was like a revelation. It was as if I had discovered the secret root of all of the stereotypes propagated for the past thirty years about the ‘old continent’ in Hollywood movies and TV. You had everything to choose from, morose Germans dressed in black bouncing away totechno beats, angry-looking yet somehow friendly Finns, playing actual instruments, growling over a death metal dirge and at least one retro-traditional, uncomfortable looking outfit that has not actually been seen in its home country in at least 150 years. I had found the secret source of inspiration that comedians like Mike Meyers and Sacha Baron Cohen had been drawing from without ever having to move from their sofas.  

My discovery came long after Eurovision was popular enough to launch the careers of singers like Spain’s own Julio Iglesias or give bands like ABBA the chance to change the meaning of Waterloo forever. It was at the turn of the century and just before the massive shift towards songs in English took over the competition. A move that turned the once popular show into something that now vaguely resembles cruise ship entertainment with unfamiliar accents trying to sing vaguely familiar sounding words. But even still, there is something endearing about Byelorussian Butterflies, bearded drag queens from Austria and transgendered women dressed as birds from Israel. It was all so exotically European that I felt like the Griswolds discovering an mysterious continent from my own sofa.

But wait, Israel? Had I missed something? Wasn’t this competition about Europe? I’ve seen the Caucasus from the southern side, crossed through the Urals and sailed across the Bosphorous and am pretty sure that, no matter how strong their lobbies are, Israel is at least a thousand kilometres south of Istanbul. They can be guests along with Morocco, Australia and other countries beyond the continent, but by definition, they can never be one of us.

One of us, a phrase that’s increasingly heard in these dark days of identity politics. Times when groups from both extremes of the spectrum gather around a diaphanous concept of shared identity while inflating differences between one of us and lo nuestro (ours) from those who don’t belong to the tribe. It’s a much darker nationalism than the spandex outfits of Eurovision. I’ve never shared the aversion that many Spaniards have for their flag, but I do have to admit that some of the flag waving last Monday carried portents of danger ahead.

What do people waving fascist flags really want? A return…but a return to what? Are the the poor souls floating across the Mediterranean an invasion designed to steal their jobs and weaken their healthcare? Or is it that a fellow ‘patriot’ is outsourcing them? Is the evil-empire Soros gang really coming to implant chips in our brains, burn down churches and eviscerate ‘our’ religion? Or is the bronze-age faith really something as European as the Israeli women dressed as birds? Something about as much ‘ours’ as Ralph Lauren, ironed Levis and made-in-China flags.

The next time lo nuestro comes up, take a minute to reflect on just how ‘ours’ it really is.


Wednesday, May 6, 2015

You're Not From Around Here


Writing in the local paper. Local issues with a global take. I never translate literally and the editor trims at will to make it fit. Here's my version, then theirs. (This time, markedly different endings.)

“Usted obviamente no eres de aquí,” (You're obviously not from around here) and while my linguistic pride may have been mortally injured, the policeman on the telephone was right, I’m not. He was right in noticing that my Spanish has inexplicably worsened this year. He went on, “Como todo los años, hay aglomeraciones en Santa Maria y es normal que no se puede pasar con su coche porque todo el mundo quiere ir al besamano.” (Like every year, there are large crowds of people in Santa Maria square and it's normal that you can't drive your car through there because everyone wants to go and kiss a virgen) But that wasn’t my question. What I was asking the policeman on the phone was why had there not been any notice posted about the road being cut in Santa Clara, the entrance to the Old Town? Why were two harassed local police officers suddenly directing all traffic into the tiny, yet full, plaza de los Caldereros and then asking them to drive against traffic back where they came from? I may be from a country far across the water but my question was why there hadn’t been any notice posted like they do in WOMAD or Semana Santa. I was calling the local police to see if for some reason I had missed the information that the road was going to be cut and what the alternative plan was. My accent aside, the policeman on the phone repeatedly told me that there was no such plan in place, that there had been no special preparations made for the event and that the poor policemen that I had questioned on the way home were only trying to mitigate a potentially dangerous situation. I felt terrible and immediately set out to apologize to the policemen but when I got the the plaza de los Caldereros, they had disappeared and in their place was a plastic barrier blocking traffic. I ran up to Santa Clara to see if they were directing traffic there, but found nothing, no police, no barrier, still no information. Back down to an overflowing Santa Maria and other than some national police guarding against what I suppose might be terrorist attacks, no local police to be found and surprisingly no emergency crews either. That policeman was right, I’m not from around here but if indeed this mass of people happens every year, I’m not sure I would only count on the virgin’s benevolence in case of an emergency. 

Thursday, May 22, 2014

Princesas de Primavera (Spring Princesses)


Writing in the local paper. Local issues with a global take. I never translate literally and the editor trims at will to make it fit. Here's my version, then theirs.

It’s the time of year for cherries, little sailor suits, Playstations and travel agents with deals on trips to Euro Disney. I happened to be invited to a communion the other day and to this guiri travel writer, these celebrations are as exotic as bullfights, Songkran in Thailand or Novrus in Iran. 

It wasn't my first, so I had an idea as what to expect but this one happened to be in one of the megachurches in one of the newer parts of the city and therefore promised a different look at an old custom. 

It's been a warm spring and that particular day was no different. The traditionally sombrely dressed men had added a bit of color and had decided to dip into their clothing reserve that is normally reserved for summer weddings but it was definitely the rather short skirts that seemed to catch everyone’s...eye. 

When the ceremony began, I found myself inside the decorated gymnasium as the nervous children walked up the aisle, the weight of their protagonism etching itself in ever slightly different ways on their serious faces. As the ceremony drew on I found myself drifting outside along with clouds of incense and a steady stream of better-dressed people. Walking around the growing crowd, I couldn’t help but eavesdrop on conversations here and there. 

Lunch seemed to be the topic of the day with the key words being where the luncheon was taking place and how many had been invited. According to many, communions were becoming like weddings in order to help with that trip to see Mickey in Paris. Sentries peeked in on the ceremony now and then and as it began to come to an end, the crowds slid back in. 

The children were now standing at the front and a crush of paparazzi formed in front, but the priest had yet to finish. The crowd grew and so did the noise as the priest strained to be heard over the hum, 'Don't forget that while today is important, it would be nice to see this enthusiasm here tomorrow (Sunday).’ I don’t often agree with sermons from the pulpit but this time he was on to something.

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

A Nestorian Epiphany in El Pais

A successful Chinese Buddhist businesswoman who professes her devotion to a 15th century crucifixtion figure gives birth to a Nestorian satori in my first piece blogging for El Pais. Of course, all framed within the slightly morbid context of the celebration here on the decidedly european Iberian peninsula of a man's death by torture so many years ago.

Sunday, April 17, 2011

Easter Redux

The scent of incense, the boom of the drums and the rattle of the snares, pushy yet well dressed crowds, dolled up children trying to be pious, hooded penitents doing the same...

It's Easter once again here in Spain.

Click over for a look from my window.

Moving Shop

  We've moved house. This blog has moved to  https://troynahumko.com/ See you over there!